1 - 20 of 539 Works in Caleb Brewster
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
Written for the Turn Week 2026 prompt "what if [BLANK] had lived?"-- I chose Samuel, and this piece explores Ben's realisation that his brother might not be able to fight again after his treatment on the Jersey.
Series
- Part 3 of Jack's Turn Week 2026 Oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
From the diary of Elisabetta Byrd Jefferson
I had thought love a thing one might keep softly and in secret, folded close to the heart where no unkind hand could reach it.
I had not considered that war would come for it.
I had not considered that the family I had lost might be given back to me in the most unlikely souls.
Nor had I considered that loving Benjamin Tallmadge would not only break my heart with fear, but make it brave enough to endure.- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 10,033
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Hits:
- 10
-
Tags
Summary
A slight rewrite of s3e3 where Ben is the one to set up the ambush at Rocky Point for Simcoe; and Caleb is sent to kill Worthington. Things go badly despite them being better suited to these tasks than the one in canon.
Rocky Point had grown into quite the little hamlet since Ben had been there last— if he remembered correctly, it had been when he was barely past his twelfth birthday. Caleb, seventeen or so at the time, had somehow requisitioned a small fishing boat and was taking Sam over the sound to fraternise with a girl he was attempting to court at the time.
Series
- Part 2 of Jack's Turn Week 2026 Oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
This has been Major Edmund Hewlett's house for nearly two hundred and fifty years, even if the living occupants of the house don't know it. When the newest set of occupants move in, he is unexpectedly confronted with the past he has never been able to let go of, and a face he has never been able to forget.
-
Tags
Summary
A oneshot stemming from me wondering exactly why Caleb ran out of camp in s4e4.
He needed to warn Townsend. Or— or maybe he was just trying to get some air, get away from the stench of death that stuck to the medical tent, he couldn't— He didn't know— He didn't know anything! Was he riding away from the camp, or riding somewhere? Was God watching him? Was God there?
Series
- Part 1 of Jack's Turn Week 2026 Oneshots
-
Of Love and War by arrthurpendragon (ocfairygodmother)
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014), American Revolution RPF, Historical RPF
04 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
As far as her father was concerned, Lydia's current feelings for Benjamin were simply that of a heartbroken girl whose childhood sweetheart had betrayed her. But the truth of the matter was that Lydia Woodhull would always love Benjamin Tallmadge, rebel or not.
-
Tags
Summary
When Caleb--Setauket University's evening janitor--is late to clean Professor Ben's office, the two childhood friends' daily routine is thrown off and a new ritual emerges; revealing more than either ever wanted to admit.
-
Tags
Summary
"The war does not care about the origin of the metal. It only cares if the blade holds its edge when the perimeter breaks."
To the High Command at Fairfield, Mistress Emma Brewster is merely a brilliant provincial orphan—a parson’s niece from the Long Island shingle whose clinical eye for ciphers makes her an asset to the regular army’s gloss.
But Major Benjamin Tallmadge knows the raw, bleeding grit behind her severe alignment. He knows the nightmare she fled across the Sound, and he knows the white-hot frequency of the vow they share in the dark.
When a stolen British ledger uncovers a catastrophic, radioactive truth about Emma’s bloodline, the structural integrity of the Culper Ring fractures from within. She isn't just a spy standing on the wall; she carries the exact, commanding geometry of the Commander-in-Chief himself.
Locked in a two-person alliance with Ben against the hyper-vigilant suspicion of Alexander Hamilton and the voyeuristic madness of John Simcoe, Emma must choose between the father who left her in a cage to keep his name pristine and the parson’s boy willing to burn the republic's maps to keep her alive.
-
I get tired and I get sick and then I lose the strength to leave by MadGreyDawn
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014)
19 Jun 2026
Tags
Summary
In the five years Ben spent in Virginia, working for John Andre, he became a willing stranger to his friends, his family, and his home. Now with Samuel gone, he moves back home to help Anna and the others run their Arts Collective in search of a peaceful life.
Only, he's living next door to a hermit, Caleb Brewster, that never leaves his flat; Nathan's sentence appeal is fast approaching and all the judges are corrupt; and Anna has a stalker that is far more involved in everything than anybody really realises.
At least the chaos in New York is fun.
-
Join or Die by Chaitea14
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014), 18th Century CE RPF, American Revolution RPF
25 May 2026
Tags
Summary
Anna Smith and Abe Woodhull's engagement has been dissolved by their fathers' clashing loyalties and ambitions in an increasingly divided New York. Judge Woodhull thinks the Smiths'—social climbers and critics of British policies—threaten his standing.
Selah Strong, the eldest of Setauket's wealthiest family, spent most of his life at Strong Manor, which looms over the town literally and figuratively. The Strongs have a reputation as pillars of society, but behind closed doors, Selah’s father is quietly funding smuggling efforts. Selah has long since been captivated by Anna, watching her from the windows of the Strong family's fortress, and begins courting her at his father's behest. What starts as a practical alliance deepens into genuine affection for Selah, but Anna finds herself bored with Selah’s gentlemanly pursuits.
As Anna brings him further from the safety of the manor's walls, Selah emerges as a leader in Long Island's Patriot circles. Anna, now Selah’s fiancée, is drawn from their whispered plans to navigate the social pressures of their impending marriage. With their marriage, Strong Manor stands as both a symbol of privilege and a hub of rebellion looming over Setauket as its fate approaches.
-
Tags
Summary
Mary and Ben have their second child. It's different this time.
(alternating points of view) 💙💛Comments welcome! 😀😆😀😆😀😆
-
Tags
Summary
Benjamin听到了一些关于Washington老师的传闻。
-
Tags
Summary
After the Battle of Monmouth, and after the interrogation of Bradford and Hickey; Caleb sneaks into Ben's tent to chat. They've been quietly scared for a long time now, and neither of them want to be alone that night.
-
Tags
Summary
Ben's point of view and feelings during and after his time with Sarah, along with delirious dreams, a heart to heart with his brother, and the aftermath of Sarah's killing.
Comments welcome/encouraged.
-
Tags
Summary
Ben and Caleb deal with the aftermath of Caleb's time with Simcoe.
-
What If They Had Gotten Together: The Battle At Moodna Creek by beta1alpha2omega3
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014)
06 Apr 2026
Tags
Summary
When Ben and Caleb go after Gamble, Caleb learns that Gamble had been the one to shoot Ben.
Series
- Part 11 of What If They Had Gotten Together?
-
What If They Had Gotten Together: Middlebrook, New Jersey by beta1alpha2omega3
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014)
23 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
Caleb had just returned with Anna from Setauket when Ben arrives back at camp, injured from his run-in with Gamble, and guilt-ridden from his encounter with Sarah. Caleb tends to Ben's wound--the walk back to camp having exacerbated the injury--and Ben confesses his feelings in a state of fever-ridden delirium.
Series
- Part 10 of What If They Had Gotten Together?
-
What If They Had Gotten Together: After Bradford's Execution by beta1alpha2omega3
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014)
22 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
Ben and Caleb negotiate what punishment Caleb should receive after his scuffle with Reverend Worthington. They discuss their feelings surrounding the execution and Caleb flirts at Ben to lighten the mood.
Series
- Part 9 of What If They Had Gotten Together?
-
What If They Had Gotten Together: The Battle At Kerr Farm by beta1alpha2omega3
Fandoms: Turn (TV 2014)
14 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
In the celebration of victory at Kerr Farm, Ben impulsively kisses Caleb, opening the floodgates to Caleb's flirtatious pursual.
Series
- Part 8 of What If They Had Gotten Together?
-
Tags
Summary
The last thing he remembered was the sound cracking through the forest, and his desperate running towards it. Injured heavily and bone-deep exhausted, Ben Tallmadge races to the small cabin (if it can be referred to as such) in the thick of the woods. Truly, the last thing he could recall was the softness of a pale hand reaching towards him- but he would never tell another soul of that.